AgentLogo

Two Story, Spanish, Single Family

2228 Starfish LN

SANIBEL, FL 33957

MLS#: 223055181

$1,495,000

Status: Closed
Listing number: 223055181
Listing provided by: Premier Sotheby's Int'l Realty
Listing agent phone: None
Last update: 2 years ago
On site: 2 years ago
Browse Properties
BUTTERKNIFE - Residential

Property

Beds

3

Full Baths

2

1/2 Baths

1

Year Built

1992

Sq.Footage

3,977

Behind the private gates of West Gulf Drive's only gated community and just across the street from the convenient deeded beach accesses is the coveted near-beach community of Butterknife. Backing up to a preserve with serene views this truly unique home boasts Spanish revival architecture in an idyllic near beach setting. The grand living room boasts two-story cathedral ceilings, fireplace, a view of a garden out front and the beautiful pool area out back. The large kitchen overlooks the preserve and the unique dining room was designed with a natural flair. The grand staircase leads up to the primary suite with large footprint, office, and bathroom with stunning preserve views. The large pool deck features a linear pool running perpendicular to the house with a hot tub and plenty of room for entertaining. A new Brava composite Spanish tile roof was just installed. The home was affected by Hurricane Ian and has been remediated down to the studs. This is an opportunity to rebuild a near-beach masterpiece.

Features & Amenities

Interior

  • Other Interior Features

    Cathedral Ceiling(s)

  • Total Bedrooms

    3

  • Bathrooms

    2

  • 1/2 Bathrooms

    1

  • Cooling YN

    YES

  • Cooling

    Ceiling Fan(s)

  • Heating YN

    YES

  • Heating

    Central, Electric

  • Pet friendly

    Yes

Exterior

  • Garage

    Yes

  • Garage spaces

    3

  • Construction Materials

    Stucco

  • Other Exterior Features

    Tennis Court(s)

  • Parking

    Attached

  • Patio and Porch Features

    Screened, Deck

  • Pool

    Yes

  • Pool Features

    Community, Private

Area & Lot

  • Lot Features

    Waterfront, Irregular Lot

  • Lot Size(acres)

    0.6084

  • Property Type

    Residential

  • Property Sub Type

    Single Family Residence

  • Architectural Style

    Two Story, Spanish, Single Family

Price

  • Sales Price

    $1,495,000

  • Tax Amount

    $21,366.98

  • Sq. Footage

    3, 977

  • Price/SqFt

    $375

HOA

  • Association

    Yes

  • Association Fee 2

    $2,145

  • Association Fee 2 Frequency

    Annually

  • Association Fee Includes

    N/A

School District

  • Elementary School

    N/A

  • Middle School

    N/A

  • High School

    N/A

Property Features

  • Stories

    2

  • Association Amenities

    Beach Access, Pool, Tennis Court(s)

  • Ownership

    Single Family

Schedule a Showing

Showing scheduled successfully.

<
>
IN PERSON
VIA CHAT

What is 3 + 4 ?


Change time

Mortgage calculator

Estimate your monthly mortgage payment, including the principal and interest, property taxes, and HOA. Adjust the values to generate a more accurate rate.

Your payment

Principal and Interest:

$

Property taxes:

$

HOA fees:

$

Total loan payment:

$

Total interest amount:

$

Location

County

Lee

Elementary School

Middle School

High School

Listing Courtesy of Jeffrey Burns , Premier Sotheby's Int'l Realty

RealHub Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. RealHub website owner shall not be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless.

Agent Julia McCabe

Agent | Realtor®

Julia McCabe

Call Julia today to schedule a private showing.

(610) 585-9923

juliamccabeswfl@gmail.com


* Listings on this website come from the FMLS IDX Compilation and may be held by brokerage firms other than the owner of this website. The listing brokerage is identified in any listing details. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. If you believe any FMLS listing contains material that infringes your copyrighted work please click here to review our DMCA policy and learn how to submit a takedown request.© 2024 FMLS.
Behind the private gates of West Gulf Drive's only gated community and just across the street from the convenient deeded beach accesses is the coveted near-beach community of Butterknife. Backing up to a preserve with serene views this truly unique home boasts Spanish revival architecture in an idyllic near beach setting. The grand living room boasts two-story cathedral ceilings, fireplace, a view of a garden out front and the beautiful pool area out back. The large kitchen overlooks the preserve and the unique dining room was designed with a natural flair. The grand staircase leads up to the primary suite with large footprint, office, and bathroom with stunning preserve views. The large pool deck features a linear pool running perpendicular to the house with a hot tub and plenty of room for entertaining. A new Brava composite Spanish tile roof was just installed. The home was affected by Hurricane Ian and has been remediated down to the studs. This is an opportunity to rebuild a near-beach masterpiece.

2228 Starfish LN

Message successfully sent.

What would you like to know?

What is 3 + 4 ?

Related Properties

New on site 1 day ago
Nestled within the sought-after The Dunes community, this lakeside Sanibel sanctuary offers the perfect blend of island lifestyle, privacy, and convenience. Ideally positioned on a quiet cul-de-sac along Sanderling Circle, the home showcases panoramic lake and preserve views with coveted southwesterly exposure—delivering magnificent sunsets each evening. Designed for relaxed coastal living, the residence features light-filled living spaces and an open flow that extends seamlessly to the outdoor lanai. The main living level is warm and inviting, highlighted by a cozy fireplace in the family room—perfect for peaceful mornings or unwinding in the evening after a day enjoying all that Sanibel has to offer. Enjoy your private pool and spacious patio, an ideal setting for entertaining or simply relaxing with family and friends in a serene island backdrop. The lower level provides generous garage space along with ample room for bikes, kayaks, beach gear, and additional storage—perfect for embracing the active Sanibel lifestyle. Residents of The Dunes enjoy optional membership to the semi-private golf and tennis club, along with pickleball and dining amenities. Spend your days golfing, playing tennis or pickleball, or biking to Sanibel’s world-renowned beaches. With two convenient entrances and exits, this location offers easy on/off island access and close proximity to the Sanibel Causeway. Whether you’re seeking a full-time residence, seasonal retreat, or investment opportunity, this home captures the essence of Sanibel as a true sanctuary island.
#2026017652

SANIBEL

1406 Sanderling CIR

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,229 Sq.Ft.

$1,425,000

MLS#: 2026017652

New on site 2 days ago
Stunning, fully renovated Gulf-access pool home! Nearly every detail has been thoughtfully updated in this beautifully designed coastal retreat reimagined. From the moment you enter, your eye is drawn through the home to the screened pool and wide canal beyond, while a comfortable open layout, large outdoor entertaining space, and tasteful finishes create an inviting atmosphere throughout. The open kitchen showcases handcrafted custom wood cabinetry, quartz countertops, and stainless steel appliances, perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. Wood-grain luxury vinyl plank flooring runs throughout the home, providing a warm, coastal aesthetic. The extensive upgrades include re-done electrical, HVAC, PEX plumbing, a hot water recirculation system, pool equipment, landscaping, lanai screening, cabinetry, designer tile showers, vanities, appliances, furnishings, and moremaking this home feel truly like new. Ideally located on a wide canal with just one bridge to open water, the property is also close to deeded beach access and the shops and restaurants of downtown and the east end of Sanibeloffering the best of island living. No Helene or Milton water intrusion.
#2026019235

SANIBEL

1040 Kings Crown DR

4 Beds

3 Baths

1,857 Sq.Ft.

$1,250,000

MLS#: 2026019235

New on site 3 days ago
Step into coastal luxury with this exceptional direct-access canal home in the highly sought-after Del Sega community on Sanibel Island. Perfectly positioned for both privacy and breathtaking water views, this elevated residence has been completely reimagined with a full top-to-bottom renovation—offering a seamless blend of modern elegance and relaxed island living. From the moment you enter, you’re greeted by soaring ceilings, abundant natural light, and an airy, open-concept design that invites the outdoors in. The stunning kitchen is a true centerpiece, featuring sleek gloss cabinetry, sophisticated grey quartz countertops, and premium stainless-steel appliances—perfect for both entertaining and everyday living. The adjoining dining area flows effortlessly onto an expansive deck, where long canal views create a picturesque backdrop for morning coffee or sunset cocktails. Enjoy the best of Southwest Florida’s wildlife right from your backyard—watch dolphins glide by, manatees surface, and herons wade gracefully along the water’s edge. Just off the living room, a spacious screened porch offers the ideal setting for year-round outdoor dining or simply unwinding while surrounded by tropical breezes and lush greenery. Upstairs, the home continues to impress with three beautifully updated bedrooms and two full baths, each designed with comfort and style in mind. Every detail has been thoughtfully considered, including major upgrades such as a newer roof, air conditioning system, water heater, Trex decking, and a private dock—providing direct gulf access to open waters with ease. Whether you’re seeking a serene full-time residence, a seasonal retreat, or an investment in paradise, this move-in-ready home truly has it all. Experience the ultimate Sanibel Island lifestyle—schedule your private showing today.
#2026019065

SANIBEL

2499 Harbour LN

3 Beds

3 Baths

1,536 Sq.Ft.

$1,399,000

MLS#: 2026019065

Introducing “Beach Therapy,” a sophisticated coastal retreat in Beachview Country Club Estates on Sanibel Island that seamlessly blends refined island living with exceptional investment potential. This impeccably maintained four-bedroom, three-bath residence offers both immediate income generation and an elegant private escape. Thoughtfully designed for comfort and effortless entertaining, the home showcases a spacious, open-concept floor plan enhanced by light-filled living areas, a gracious family room, and an inviting sunroom. Coastal-inspired interiors, curated finishes, and a serene color palette create a timeless aesthetic, while a well-appointed bunk room provides flexible accommodations for guests and extended family. The outdoor living experience is equally compelling, featuring a private screened lanai with a heated pool and desirable southern exposure, delivering abundant natural light throughout the day. This tranquil setting offers the perfect backdrop for relaxed afternoons or intimate gatherings, embodying the essence of resort-style living. Ideally positioned to enjoy Sanibel Island’s world-renowned shelling beaches, scenic bike paths, inshore and offshore boating and fishing, this exceptional property captures the true spirit of coastal luxury. With its generous accommodations, and turnkey appeal, “Beach Therapy” represents a rare opportunity to acquire a distinctive island residence with both lifestyle and investment appeal and offers a short walk to a private deeded beach access.
#2026018843

SANIBEL

1251 Par View DR

4 Beds

3 Baths

2,515 Sq.Ft.

$1,375,000

MLS#: 2026018843

Welcome to Seagull Estates, the most sought-after neighborhood on Sanibel Island. This sophisticated beach house offers 3 bedrooms (one of which is a large, private master suite) plus an office/den, 2.5 baths and deeded beach access to the Gulf of Mexico just a short walk away. Hardwood floors flow throughout the spacious open floor plan. A wood burning fireplace anchors the living area-perfect for those rare cool winter nights. The large kitchen features a generous island and coffered – ceiling, is ideal for family gatherings and opens seamlessly into the dining area. Both the living area and kitchen spill out onto an extensive screened porch/lanai that spans the entire length of the house....great for relaxation, sunning or entertaining, and overlooking a serene lake alive with coastal birds and wildlife. Nestled on Christofer Court – the only cul-de-sac in the subdivision – this home offers both privacy and tranquility. Seagull Estates residents enjoy access to a community pool, clubhouse, tennis court and pickleball courts. Being sold furnished with exceptions. Inventory available.
#2026017866

SANIBEL

246 Christofer CT

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,808 Sq.Ft.

$1,379,000

MLS#: 2026017866

Sanibel; named by Travel & Leisure as one of the top 50 “Best Places” internationally to visit, with its restaurants, shops and of course, Sanibel’s incredible beaches, rebuilt and open for business. Located in the resort zone and historically operated as a vacation daily rental, this quaint 3 unit Inn is part of that comeback, booking reservations since reopening in March 2024. This gem is a once in a lifetime opportunity for a buyer looking for an impressive income stream. Just steps away from the Donax St beach, it has consistently been a priority destination for visiting tourists that love Sanibel for its shells, beaches and small town vibe. New Central Air Conditioner, new furniture and enhancements in upper unit. The other 2 units have been rebuilt in totality, ground up. Also new roof, new siding, new landscaping, we have focused on each part of the process with forethought and care to make this again a destination for guests throughout the Country and Internationally. This Inn has been rented on the major online accounts since 2017 and has built up a reputation for consistent bookings. 2026 calendar is already booking out, so a buyer will close with income already in place. In addition, many previous guests book direct and come back year after year. This special property is a 100 year land lease with over 50 years remaining and a smart and stable investment without the volatility of other investment options. With all the working policies and procedures already in place, a new owner can virtually take over an established business, streamlined with proven efficiencies and income.
#226016144

SANIBEL

610 Donax ST 311

5 Beds

3 Baths

2,500 Sq.Ft.

$1,475,000

MLS#: 226016144

Here's your opportunity to own a slice of paradise at the coveted Sanibel Gulf-front community of Compass Point! This corner/end unit has unbelievable beach and gulf views that dreams are made of. The floor to ceiling sliders allow you to enjoy the serene gulf waters and swaying palms when you wake up in the primary bedroom, while relaxing in the living room, making breakfast in the kitchen, or dining on the lanai! The screened and glass enclosed lanai spans the entire width of the unit, with spiral staircase that goes directly down to private cabana. This unique setup gives you extra (air conditioned) space (307 additional SF) for entertaining, with additional studio-type space with 3/4 bath, wet bar, and direct beach access. The cabana space also provides plenty of space to store your bikes and beach gear, right on ground level. From your cabana, head straight to the white sand on the newly built boardwalk. This unit has undergone complete remediation after hurricane Ian, is furnished turnkey, and ready to call home. Compass Point allows weekly rentals, and this unit has had consistent, long-term rental history-- for those who may want extra income while not occupying the unit themselves. Heated pool and pool house updated, along with new tennis and pickleball courts, gas grills, and bocce court. Don't wait another minute to create memories in your beautiful Sanibel beach condo!
#2026017623

SANIBEL

1299 Middle Gulf DR 191

3 Beds

3 Baths

1,358 Sq.Ft.

$1,399,000

MLS#: 2026017623

Wake up each day to sweeping, unobstructed views of the Gulf from this beautifully positioned east end island condominium, where endless blue water and breathtaking sunset skies become part of your everyday life. Expansive windows and sliders, recently upgraded to impact glass, frame the coastline from nearly every room and fill the interior with natural light and the soothing backdrop of the sea. The spacious open living and dining areas flow seamlessly to a large, enclosed lanai, creating the perfect setting to relax, entertain, or simply take in the ever-changing Gulf views. Whether enjoying morning coffee with gentle waves in the distance or evening cocktails as the sun dips below the horizon, this home captures the essence of coastal living. The kitchen is both functional and inviting, featuring granite countertops, ample cabinetry, and a layout that connects effortlessly to the main living space. Granite surfaces continue into the bathrooms, adding a cohesive and timeless finish throughout. The generously sized primary suite offers comfort and privacy, while the guest bedroom and an enclosed den with doors and a window provide flexible space currently utilized as a third sleeping area, ideal for accommodating additional guests or creating a private office or retreat. Offered furnished, this residence is move-in ready and ideal as a personal retreat or investment opportunity. Additional features include exterior storage and convenient under-building parking. Residents enjoy a well-appointed community with elevator access, direct beach access, a pool, and tennis and pickleball courts, everything needed to embrace the relaxed island lifestyle. Located on the desirable east end of the island, this property offers a quieter, more relaxed setting while still being just moments from local dining and shopping. Its convenient location near the Causeway allows for easy on and off island access, making trips to the mainland simple while still enjoying everything island living has to offer. The association allows for 30-day minimum rentals, providing flexibility for both personal use and income potential.
#2026016537

SANIBEL

635 E Gulf DR A202

2 Beds

2 Baths

2,600 Sq.Ft.

$1,699,000

MLS#: 2026016537

Nestled within the highly sought-after Gulf Pines community, this charming 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of privacy, nature, and timeless Sanibel character. Tucked away among lush native vegetation, Gulf Pines is known for its peaceful setting, Old Florida feel, and spacious homesites—creating a true island retreat. Step inside and discover a comfortable and inviting layout designed for easy coastal living, with generous living spaces and a natural flow that makes both everyday living and entertaining a breeze. Whether you’re hosting friends or enjoying a quiet evening at home, this residence captures the relaxed elegance that defines life on Sanibel. Gulf Pines residents enjoy exclusive access to a beautifully maintained community clubhouse—perfect for gatherings and social events—Two swimming pools, as well as tennis courts for an active island lifestyle. Meandering paths wind through the neighborhood, leading you directly to one of Sanibel’s most breathtaking stretches of beach, where shelling, sunsets, and the soothing sound of the Gulf become part of your daily routine. Living here means embracing the very best of the Sanibel lifestyle—morning bike rides along scenic paths, afternoons on the beach, and evenings surrounded by nature’s beauty. If you’ve been searching for a home that offers both tranquility and connection to everything that makes Sanibel so special, this Gulf Pines gem is your opportunity to start. Helping you live the sunshine you’ve been dreaming of!
#2026010117

SANIBEL

4209 Old Banyan WAY

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,146 Sq.Ft.

$1,250,000

MLS#: 2026010117

Beautiful, strong, elevated, and worry-free! Built in 2016 by Seacoast Cottage Company, this striking Key West style home has a relaxed and inviting feel with its open plan, high ceilings, and wrap-around verandas. Lots of natural light showcases the quality finishes throughout, which includes cypress tongue and groove ceilings, gorgeous walnut engineered wood flooring, and curbless showers. A vibrant Cuban-style backsplash made with hand-crafted tiles is the focal point of the kitchen and is both warm and welcoming. The split bedroom plan has a spacious primary suite. There is plenty of closet space and privacy. An elevator leads from the ground level to the upstairs loft with two home offices or dens on each end. Fortified with impact resistant doors, windows, metal roof, and Hardie Board siding. This lovely property looks out onto conservation land providing peaceful nature views, rest and relaxation. Conveniently located in the popular Dunes Golf & Tennis community, close to the Sanibel causeway, shops and restaurants. Deeded beach access. Permitted for a future pool. All this and very low insurance rates.
#2026016881

SANIBEL

1428 Albatross RD

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,392 Sq.Ft.

$1,295,000

MLS#: 2026016881

- property

Send a message

Message successfully sent.

Your message

What is 3 + 4 ?

Reason for contacting?

Sign Out

Virtual Assistant

Would you like to take the next step with this property? We can help you schedule a showing or virtual tour, or send you more details.

Yes, I would like more information.

Thank You for Your Reply, One of Our Agents will contact you as soon as possible

No, maybe later.

Thank you, you can always contact me via email, phone number or through the contact form.

Realhub AI

Lucy - Your AI-Powered Realtor

Update Your Temporary Password

Personalize your search

Enter your email and we'll notify you immediately when new listings match what you're looking for.

or enter email address

Already have an account ? Login here

Continue your home search

Already have an account ? Login here

We use cookies

We use cookies primarily for analytics to enhance your experience. By accepting, you agree to our use of these cookies. You can manage your preferences or learn more about our cookies policy.

Privacy Policy Terms of Service